Imagine this: the Atlanta Braves, a team known for their strategic moves, are facing a critical decision that could shape their future. What happens at shortstop after 2026? It’s a question that’s been lingering since the team decided not to re-sign Dansby Swanson after the 2022 season—a move that now seems more significant than anyone realized at the time. Since then, the Braves have experimented with no fewer than eleven different players at shortstop, but only Orlando Arcia’s magical first half of 2023 came close to league-average performance. And this is the part most people miss: the position remains a glaring question mark for 2027, despite Ha-Seong Kim and Mauricio Dubón currently holding down the fort for 2026. Both are set to become free agents after this season, leaving the Braves at a crossroads. But here’s where it gets controversial: should the Braves extend Kim, pivot to Dubón, or explore other options? Let’s dive in.
For 2026, the Braves seem set with Kim, who signed a one-year, $20 million deal, and Dubón, acquired as a reliable backup. However, both players’ contracts expire after this season, forcing the Braves to plan ahead. Kim, represented by Scott Boras, is aiming for a strong 2026 to boost his free-agent value, especially after a subpar 2025 marred by injuries and poor performance. If he returns to his 2023 form—when he posted a 107 OPS+ and stole 38 bases—he’ll be one of the most sought-after free agents next winter. But will the Braves, with their self-imposed $22 million salary cap, be able to retain him? Or will they risk losing him to a qualifying offer and a draft pick as compensation?
Here’s the bold part: an early extension for Kim might be the smartest move, despite Boras’s reputation for pushing clients to free agency. It’s not unheard of—Matt Chapman signed a similar deal before hitting the market. Plus, Kim’s friendship with Jurickson Profar, who’s under contract with the Braves through 2028, could sway his decision. But if Kim tests the market, the Braves might turn to Dubón, whose defensive prowess is undeniable but whose offensive decline raises concerns. Since becoming a full-time starter in 2023, Dubón’s OPS+ has dropped from 97 to 78 last season. While his versatility—he’s played every position except catcher and won two utility Gold Gloves—is a strength, relying on him as the everyday shortstop could exacerbate the team’s injury woes.
Beyond Kim and Dubón, the free-agent market for shortstops in 2027 is thin. J.P. Crawford and Amed Rosario are the next best options, but neither matches Kim’s potential. This scarcity could push the Braves to explore trades. Names like Jeremy Peña, CJ Abrams, and Zach Neto could be targets, though acquiring them would likely require significant assets. Alternatively, veterans like Corey Seager or Trevor Story might be available, but their contracts come with financial baggage. Then there’s the wildcard: Matt McLain of the Cincinnati Reds. A former shortstop with speed and defensive skills, McLain could be a high-risk, high-reward option if he rebounds from injuries and a slumping bat.
Here’s the thought-provoking question: Should the Braves prioritize short-term competitiveness or long-term stability? Extending Kim or trading for a young talent like Peña might secure the position for years, but it could also limit flexibility. On the other hand, relying on Dubón or a stopgap solution could leave the team vulnerable in 2027. The Braves’ front office, led by Alex Anthopoulos, must balance these factors while keeping an eye on the next CBA and the team’s competitive window.
As fans, we’re left wondering: Will the Braves make a bold move to secure their shortstop for the future, or will they play it safe and risk uncertainty? One thing’s for sure—the decision they make now will shape their championship aspirations for years to come. What do you think? Should they extend Kim, trust Dubón, or go all-in on a trade? Let’s debate it in the comments!
