Could a power-hitting All-Star be the unexpected answer to the Boston Red Sox's backup catcher problem? It might sound crazy, but hear me out.
The Red Sox have been openly searching for someone to provide support behind the plate for Carlos Narvaez in the 2026 season. But the solution might already be on the roster: Willson Contreras.
Remember how Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow traded for Contreras from the St. Louis Cardinals? The initial plan was for the 33-year-old to primarily play first base. But here's where it gets interesting... Contreras actually started his career as a catcher with the Chicago Cubs, and he's now expressing a willingness to return to the position.
According to Jen McCaffrey of The Athletic, "Contreras said on a video call this week with reporters he’s willing to play catcher, where he’s spent the majority of his career before transitioning to first base. He might see some time behind the plate, but the Red Sox prefer him to stick at first base and DH for now.”
Contreras was a full-time catcher as recently as 2021, showcasing his experience and capabilities. He then transitioned into a role that included regular reps as a designated hitter starting in 2022. While he signed with the Cardinals before the 2023 season, they didn't move him to first base until the 2025 campaign. This relatively recent shift suggests he could still be a viable option behind the plate.
Now, let's be realistic. It might seem like a long shot to consider Contreras as Boston’s primary backup catcher. And this is the part most people miss... just because it seems unlikely doesn't mean it's impossible, especially given his willingness.
However, the Red Sox are still actively exploring other options. As Sean McAdam of Masslive.com reports, "It’s gone mostly under the radar, but the Red Sox remain active in their pursuit of an upgrade to their second catcher spot."
McAdam further notes, "The Sox were very much involved with free agent Victor Caratini, who took a two-year deal with Minnesota on Friday, hours after the Phillies re-signed J.T. Realmuto. Philadelphia had seen Caratini as a cheaper alternative to Realmuto had they succeeded in landing Bo Bichette."
The search has been ongoing for quite some time. "The Sox’ search to land someone to pair with Carlos Narvaez has been ongoing since last summer,” McAdam adds. “They contacted the White Sox to see if they would consider trading Kyle Teel back to them, and showed interest in the Dodgers’ Dalton Rushing.”
So, where does that leave us? "A month out from spring training, Connor Wong is still the No. 2 catcher, but his hold on the position is tenuous,” McAdam concludes. Wong's struggles in 2025, hitting just .190 with a .500 OPS in 63 games, certainly don't solidify his claim to the role. But here's where it gets controversial... some analysts argue that Wong's defensive capabilities outweigh his offensive shortcomings, making him a valuable asset regardless. Others disagree, pointing to the need for a more well-rounded player in such a crucial position.
Ultimately, the Red Sox have a fascinating decision to make. Do they stick with Wong, pursue another free agent, or take a chance on Contreras returning to his catching roots? This is a developing story, so stay tuned!
What do you think? Should the Red Sox give Contreras a shot at backup catcher, or should they focus on finding someone else? And do you believe Connor Wong deserves to keep his spot? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!
